The Senedd has rejected calls to overhaul planning processes for quarries in Wales, despite concerns about public health. Plaid Cymru MS Heledd Fychan proposed a debate calling for quarries not to be permitted near homes, with a mandatory buffer zone of 1,000 metres for new and existing quarries. Fychan highlighted the need to assess risks to the environment, biodiversity, and public health as part of the planning process.
She pointed out discrepancies in the planning system, citing the example of Craig-yr-Hesg in Glyncoch, where quarry expansion plans faced local opposition despite over 400 objections. The debate also saw Labour and Conservative members offering contrasting views. Labour’s Hefin David emphasised the importance of local decision-making, while Conservative Mark Isherwood expressed concerns about potential negative impacts on jobs from the proposed buffer zone.
In response, Rebecca Evans, the Welsh Government representative, stressed the significance of a sustainable mineral supply for economic development. She defended the current planning policy’s flexibility and nuanced approach, expressing reservations about introducing new legislation. While the proposal was ultimately rejected by a vote of 18-14 with 15 abstentions, Evans indicated a willingness to review existing guidance from 2004.
The debate highlighted the intricate balance between economic interests and environmental concerns in quarry planning processes. Although the proposed changes were not adopted, the discussions underscored the ongoing challenges in addressing public health and environmental considerations in quarry developments in Wales.